ISO/TR 22572:2026
(Main)Ophthalmic optics — Spectacle lenses — Measurement of refractive index
- Abstract
This document describes the possible methods of determining the refractive index of spectacle lenses, whether in uncut, cut or final mounted form. It lists several destructive and non-destructive test methods having different accuracies.
- Status
- Published
- Publication Date
- 15-Nov-2026
- Technical Committee
- ISO/TC 172/SC 7 - Ophthalmic optics and instruments
- Drafting Committee
- ISO/TC 172/SC 7 - Ophthalmic optics and instruments
- Current Stage
- 6060 - International Standard published
- Start Date
- 16-Nov-2026
- Completion Date
- 16-Nov-2026
ISO/TR 22572:2026 is an ISO Technical Report on measuring the refractive index of spectacle lenses. It describes destructive and non-destructive methods for uncut, cut, and final mounted lenses, and it is written for people who need to compare lens materials or verify a manufacturer’s claimed index.
This report is especially useful where a finished spectacle lens should be checked without being ruined. It gives a practical overview of several measurement approaches with different accuracies, from traditional prism methods to newer interferometric and prism-coupled instruments.
What does ISO/TR 22572:2026 specify?
ISO/TR 22572:2026 describes possible ways to determine the refractive index of spectacle lenses in uncut, cut, or final mounted form. The report compares destructive and non-destructive methods and sets the context for choosing a method based on available equipment, required accuracy, and whether the lens may be damaged.
The document is organized into eight main clauses and five informative annexes.
| Annex | What it covers |
|---|---|
| Annex A | Comparison of the different destructive methods |
| Annex B | Expected uncertainty when used with spectacle lens samples |
| Annex C | Group refractive index and phase refractive index |
| Annex D | Discussion of the surface power method |
| Annex E | Details of refractive index matching liquids |
Clause 4 addresses laboratory temperature. Clauses 5, 6, 7, and 8 cover traditional destructive methods, classical non-destructive methods, newer non-destructive methods, and a prism coupled refractometer.
What are the key points of ISO/TR 22572:2026?
ISO/TR 22572:2026 is not a test standard with one single method. Instead, it shows several methods that can be used on spectacle lenses, explains how they work, and points out the practical limits of each method.
Laboratory temperature matters
Clause 4 says measurement can be carried out at ambient laboratory temperature, usually either 23 °C or 27 °C, according to national practice. In practice, this means the work can be done under normal lab conditions, but the temperature should be controlled enough to support the accuracy needed for refractive index measurement.
Destructive methods require sample preparation
Clause 5 covers the minimum deviation method, the V-block method, and the Abbe refractometer. These methods generally require a prism or slab to be cut from the lens, with polished edges or a flat surface, so they are suitable for stock lenses but not for a wearer’s finished lens when damage must be avoided.
The minimum deviation method uses a goniometer or spectrometer and relies on prism geometry and Snell’s law. The V-block method uses a 90° prism in a V-block refractometer and may use a refractive index matching liquid to reduce scattered light. The Abbe refractometer uses the critical angle with a contacting liquid and is limited by the refractive index of the instrument prism and the sample.
Accuracy depends strongly on preparation and geometry
Clause 5.4 states that, for spectacle lenses, a minimum accuracy of 0.01 is expected. The report also shows that destructive methods are affected by how well the sample is cut, polished, and aligned, so the practical result may be less precise than ideal theory suggests.
This matters because a lab or buyer should not assume that the theoretical capability of the instrument is the same as the result on an actual spectacle lens sample.
Classical non-destructive methods use lens shape and power
Clause 6 explains methods based on sagittal depth, radius of curvature, vertex power, and immersion. These approaches can avoid destroying the lens, which is their main advantage for finished eyewear and for verifying claims on the final product.
The report shows that the sag formula can be used to estimate radius of curvature, and then the surface power equations can be used to derive refractive index. It also explains why errors in sag measurement, surface asphericity, and lens power can affect the result, especially for progressive or otherwise non-spherical surfaces.
Immersion methods need careful orientation and the right meridian
Clause 6.2 explains that immersing the lens in a known medium changes the measured vertex power, allowing the refractive index to be derived. For astigmatic lenses, the same meridian should be used in air and in the medium, and the more steeply curved surface should be oriented toward the support when possible.
In practice, this means the method is sensitive to how the lens is held and measured. The report also notes that power-variation lenses can be difficult because the measured area may not represent the whole lens.
New methods include low-coherence interferometry
Clause 7 describes low-coherence interferometry, which measures optical path differences and can derive the group refractive index [GRI]. The report then shows how the phase refractive index [PRI] can be calculated from GRI, with Annex C explaining the relationship in more detail.
This is important because some modern devices can measure finished spectacle lenses quickly and without cutting them. The report also notes that some instruments can measure multiple wavelengths and estimate the Abbe number.
Prism coupled refractometry can measure finished lenses without sample preparation
Clause 8 describes a prism-coupled refractometer based on the critical angle at the interface between a reference prism and the lens. No sample preparation is needed, and the prism rests on the convex surface of the lens.
The practical caution is that coated lenses may be measured as a coating-plus-substrate system, so the result may reflect the effective index of the coating rather than the substrate material alone.
What terms does ISO/TR 22572:2026 define?
- V-block prism - A prism with a 90° channel made from optical glass with a known refractive index.
- refractive index matching liquid - A transparent liquid whose refractive index is close to that of the specimen.
- contacting liquid - A transparent liquid whose refractive index is higher than that of the specimen.
- group refractive index (GRI) - The refractive index used for pulse or wave-packet propagation in the low-coherence interferometry section.
- phase refractive index (PRI) - The refractive index at a specified wavelength, derived from GRI in Annex C.
- vertex power - The lens power used in the non-destructive methods to relate measured power changes to refractive index.
- Abbe refractometer - An instrument that measures refractive index by the critical-angle principle with a prism and a contacting liquid.
Who uses ISO/TR 22572:2026?
ISO/TR 22572:2026 is relevant to spectacle lens manufacturers, test laboratories, optical instrument users, and trading standards authorities. The introduction says it was prepared to help identify methods that can determine the refractive index of finished spectacle lenses and to support verification of manufacturers’ claims.
It is also useful for quality control staff, buyers, and optical technicians who need to choose between destructive and non-destructive checking. Because the report compares methods with different accuracies and sample-preparation demands, it helps users decide whether they need a laboratory method, a production check, or a finished-lens verification method.
Which standards are used with ISO/TR 22572:2026?
- ISO 9802 - Provides vocabulary for raw optical glass, supporting the terminology used in the report.
- ISO 13666 - Provides vocabulary for spectacle lenses, which helps keep the optical terms consistent.
- ISO 80000-1 - Supports the general use of quantities and units.
- ISO 80000-3 - Supports the use of space and time quantities and units.
- ISO 21395-1 - Gives detailed instructions for the minimum deviation method used in clause 5.1.
- ISO 21395-2 - Gives detailed instructions for the V-block refractometer method used in clause 5.2.
- ISO 489 - Is cited for the critical-angle refractometer principle and for handling contacting liquids.
What does the ISO/TR 22572:2026 document contain?
The document contains schematic figures for the minimum deviation method, the V-block refractometer, the Abbe refractometer, immersion methods, low-coherence interferometry, and the prism coupled refractometer. It also contains equations for sag, surface power, immersion measurement, interferometry, and critical-angle calculation.
Annex A compares destructive methods, Annex B reports experimental uncertainty on spectacle lens samples, Annex C explains how GRI and PRI are related, Annex D discusses surface power errors, and Annex E lists refractive index matching liquids. The report also includes worked experimental results and practical notes on sample preparation, measurement orientation, coating effects, and liquid selection.
Get Certified
Connect with accredited certification bodies for this standard

BSI Group
BSI (British Standards Institution) is the business standards company that helps organizations make excellence a habit.

TÜV Rheinland
TÜV Rheinland is a leading international provider of technical services.

TÜV SÜD
TÜV SÜD is a trusted partner of choice for safety, security and sustainability solutions.
Sponsored listings
Frequently Asked Questions
ISO/TR 22572:2026 is a technical report published by the International Organization for Standardization (ISO). Its full title is "Ophthalmic optics — Spectacle lenses — Measurement of refractive index". This standard covers: This document describes the possible methods of determining the refractive index of spectacle lenses, whether in uncut, cut or final mounted form. It lists several destructive and non-destructive test methods having different accuracies.
This document describes the possible methods of determining the refractive index of spectacle lenses, whether in uncut, cut or final mounted form. It lists several destructive and non-destructive test methods having different accuracies.
ISO/TR 22572:2026 is classified under the following ICS (International Classification for Standards) categories: 11.040.70 - Ophthalmic equipment. The ICS classification helps identify the subject area and facilitates finding related standards.
ISO/TR 22572:2026 is available in PDF format for immediate download after purchase. The document can be added to your cart and obtained through the secure checkout process. Digital delivery ensures instant access to the complete standard document.
Standards Content (Sample)
Technical
Report
ISO/TR 22572
First edition
Ophthalmic optics — Spectacle
2026-11
lenses — Measurement of refractive
index
Optique ophtalmique — Verres de lunettes — Mesurage de
l'indice de réfraction
Reference number
© ISO 2026
All rights reserved.
This ISO publication is protected by copyright and is owned by ISO and/or its licensors.
The content of this ISO publication is provided under licence, not sold. Use is subject to the applicable licence terms issued by ISO,
an ISO member body, or an authorized third-party distributor.
Except as required for implementation or expressly permitted by a separate licence, no part of this ISO publication may be
reproduced, distributed, modified, used, or made available in any form or by any means - electronic or mechanical, including
photocopying, scanning, recording, or posting on internal or external digital platforms.
Any use beyond the scope of the granted rights is prohibited and may result in legal action.
ISO copyright office
CP 401 • CH-1214 Vernier, Geneva
Phone: +41 22 749 01 11
Email: copyright@iso.org
Website: www.iso.org
Published in Switzerland
ii
Contents Page
Foreword .iv
Introduction .v
1 Scope . 1
2 Normative references . 1
3 Terms and definitions . 1
4 Laboratory temperature . 2
5 Traditional destructive methods . 2
5.1 Minimum deviation method .2
5.2 V-block method . . .2
5.3 Abbe refractometer .3
5.4 Practical results .4
6 “Classical” non-destructive methods . 5
6.1 Sagittal depth gauge and radius of curvature methods .5
6.1.1 Accurate theory and considerations .5
6.1.2 Approximate or simplified theory and considerations .6
6.2 Immersion methods .7
6.2.1 Theory .7
6.2.2 Measurement apparatus – Go-Meisan method .8
6.2.3 Another immersion method .8
7 “New” non-destructive methods .12
7.1 Low-coherence interferometry . 12
7.2 Measuring apparatus . 13
8 Prism coupled refractometer . 14
8.1 Theory .14
Annex A (informative) Comparison of the different destructive methods .16
Annex B (informative) Expected uncertainty when used with spectacle lens samples . 17
Annex C (informative) Group refractive index and phase refractive index .22
Annex D (informative) Discussion – surface power method .24
Annex E (informative) Details of refractive index matching liquids .26
Bibliography .27
iii
Foreword
ISO (the International Organization for Standardization) is a worldwide federation of national standards
bodies (ISO member bodies). The work of preparing International Standards is normally carried out through
ISO technical committees. Each member body interested in a subject for which a technical committee
has been established has the right to be represented on that committee. International organizations,
governmental and non-governmental, in liaison with ISO, also take part in the work. ISO collaborates closely
with the International Electrotechnical Commission (IEC) on all matters of electrotechnical standardization.
The procedures used to develop this document and those intended for its further maintenance are described
in the ISO/IEC Directives, Part 1. In particular, the different approval criteria needed for the different types
of ISO documents should be noted. This document was drafted in accordance with the editorial rules of the
ISO/IEC Directives, Part 2 (see www.iso.org/directives).
ISO draws attention to the possibility that the implementation of this document may involve the use of (a)
patent(s). ISO takes no position concerning the evidence, validity or applicability of any claimed patent
rights in respect thereof. As of the date of publication of this document, ISO had not received notice of (a)
patent(s) which may be required to implement this document. However, implementers are cautioned that
this may not represent the latest information, which may be obtained from the patent database available at
www.iso.org/patents. ISO shall not be held responsible for identifying any or all such patent rights.
Any trade name used in this document is information given for the convenience of users and does not
constitute an endorsement.
For an explanation of the voluntary nature of standards, the meaning of ISO specific terms and expressions
related to conformity assessment, as well as information about ISO's adherence to the World Trade
Organization (WTO) principles in the Technical Barriers to Trade (TBT), see www.iso.org/iso/foreword.html.
This document was prepared by Technical Committee ISO/TC 172, Optics and photonics, Subcommittee SC 7,
Ophthalmic optics and instruments.
iv
Introduction
This document results from work in ISO/TC 172/SC 7/WG 3 to identify methods that could determine the
refractive index of spectacle lenses with the aim of being able to differentiate between the refractive index of
finished spectacle lenses. This would enable trading standards authorities to verify manufacturers' claims
on their products.
Three methods of measurement of the refractive index of optical materials have been standardized, the
minimum deviation method in ISO 21395-1, the V-block refractometer method in ISO 21395-2, as well as
the Abbe refractometer method. These methods use specialised instruments and require either a prism to
be cut out of the plane of the lens and the cut edges polished or a zone on the front surface to be surfaced
flat and polished. Hence, although they can be used to measure the properties of stock spectacle lenses,
they cannot be applied to a wearer’s spectacle lenses since they are ruined. For optimum results, two of the
methods require specialised contacting liquids of similar index to that of the lens under test. Care is needed
with the contacting liquid if it presents an environmental and health hazard during handling, storage, and
disposal – see the warning in ISO 489.
In general, there is no restriction on the value of the refractive index of finished spectacle lenses, but it can
be necessary to determine the refractive index of finished spectacle lenses and whether the index is what
the manufacturer claims it to be. Both the industry and spectacle wearers prefer a non-destructive method
to be used to check the lenses, since these methods do not harm the products. For example, the methods that
combine vertex power measurements and either the sagittal depth gauge and radius of curvature or the
immersion methods have no specific instruments for determining the refractive index. In addition, there are
some recent devices in the market that provide refractive index measurement for finished spectacle lenses,
such as critical angle and interferometric based measurements.
This document is intended to aid in measuring the refractive index of spectacle lenses and improve the
communications between spectacle manufacturers and customers. For the purposes of spectacle lenses, an
accuracy of 0,01 is expected as the minimum requirement.
v
Technical Report ISO/TR 22572:2026(en)
Ophthalmic optics — Spectacle lenses — Measurement of
refractive index
1 Scope
This document describes the possible methods of determining the refractive index of spectacle lenses,
whether in uncut, cut or final mounted form.
It lists several destructive and non-destructive test methods having different accuracies.
2 Normative references
The following documents are referred to in the text in such a way that some or all of their content constitutes
requirements of this document. For dated references, only the edition cited applies. For undated references,
the latest edition of the referenced document (including any amendments) applies.
ISO 9802, Raw optical glass — Vocabulary
ISO 13666, Ophthalmic optics — Spectacle lenses — Vocabulary
ISO 80000-1, Quantities and units — Part 1: General
ISO 80000-3, Quantities and units — Part 3: Space and time
3 Terms and definitions
For the purposes of this document, the terms and definitions given in ISO 9802, ISO 13666, ISO 80000-1,
ISO 80000-3 and the following apply.
ISO and IEC maintain terminology databases for use in standardization at the following addresses:
— ISO Online browsing platform: available at https:// www .iso .org/ obp
— IEC Electropedia: available at https:// www .electropedia .org/
3.1
V-block prism
prism with a 90° channel manufactured from optical glass with a known refractive index
[SOURCE: ISO 21395-2:2022, 3.1, modified — The words “with a 90° channel” were added.]
3.2
refractive index matching liquid
transparent liquid having the refractive index close to that of the specimen
[SOURCE: ISO 21395-2:2022, 3.2]
3.3
contacting liquid
transparent liquid having the refractive index higher than the specimen
4 Laboratory temperature
For the precision required for this purpose, measurement can be at ambient laboratory temperature, which
is usually either (23 ± 5) °C or (27 ± 5) °C in accordance with national practice.
NOTE The temperature of 23 °C is normally the standard laboratory temperature in temperate areas while 27 °C
is the standard laboratory temperature in tropical and subtropical areas.
5 Traditional destructive methods
5.1 Minimum deviation method
This method uses a goniometer or spectrometer and requires a prism with a (55 ± 10)° apical angle to be cut
out of the plane of the lens, and the surfaces of the two cut edges polished – see Figure 1. For a comparison of
the different destructive methods see Annex A.
Key
1 laser or light source, slit and collimator
2 turntable, with angular scale
3 prism cut from spectacle lens
4 detector or viewing telescope
Figure 1 — Schematic diagram of the minimum deviation method
The apical angle of the prism is measured by reflecting light from the collimator part of the instrument
from the two adjacent surfaces and viewing the reflected beam in the telescope. The relative positions of
the collimator, telescope and orientation of the prism are then adjusted to allow light from the collimator
to pass through the prism and be viewed in the telescope. The angle of incidence on the first face of the
prism is then adjusted to find the minimum angle of deviation. At this angle, the ray path through the prism
is symmetrical, so that the final angle of refraction equals the angle of incidence. The refractive index is
calculated using Snell’s law and the geometry of the apical angle and angle of incidence. Detailed instructions
for applying this method are specified in ISO 21395-1.
5.2 V-block method
This method uses a V-block refractometer and requires a 90° prism to be cut out of the plane of the lens,
and the two cut edges polished. The prism is then mounted in the V-block, which is effectively a parallel
sided block of glass with a V-shaped trough into which the prism is placed – see Figure 2. Although shown
in Figure 2, the refractive index matching liquid is not required if the cut edges are precisely prepared and
well polished. The liquid, which has a similar refractive index to that of the lens under test, reduces the
scattered light when entering and leaving the lens prism if the surfaces are not well polished, thus improving
precision. The liquid can be chosen initially on the basis of the claimed refractive index and by making a first
measurement and then, if necessary, using that result to make an improved choice of liquid and measuring a
second time. Details of some refractive index matching liquids are given in Annex E. The prism samples used
in the experiments reported in Annex B were prepared using a spectacle lens edging machine.
The final angle of refraction/deviation through the prism assembly enables the refractive index of the lens
to be calculated. Detailed instructions for applying this method are specified in ISO 21395-2.
Key
1 V-block
2 prism cut from spectacle lens
3 refractive index matching liquid
Figure 2 — Schematic diagram of the V-block refractometer
The introduction to ISO 21395-2 states:
“The minimum deviation method is most accurate in refractive index measurement but requires an advanced
technical skill to prepare a specimen with a precise shape and to measure the refractive index.”
“In contrast the V-block refractometer method is easier and faster when preparing a specimen and requires
less technical skill for measurement.”
The standard describes the potential trade-offs between the tolerance on the 90° apical angle of the prism
and the refractive index difference between the refractive index matching liquid and the (lens) prism. The
preferred tolerance for the apical angle of the prism is ±2’ arc.
5.3 Abbe refractometer
This method uses an Abbe refractometer and requires a slab of material to be cut out of the plane of the lens
with dimensions suitable to fit on the fixed prism of the instrument.
This is then surfaced flat. A contacting liquid of similar (i.e. a refractive index matching liquid) or higher
refractive index than that of the lens material is used to couple the sample to the refractometer. The method
is described in ISO 489 but basically relies on the measurement of the critical angle, that is with, preferably
monochromatic, light from a diffuse source entering the sample and passing at grazing incidence into the
instrument's prism – see Figure 3. The ray shown identifies the direction of these rays, while rays that had
a smaller angle of incidence in the sample all lie above this direction. A telescope is usually used to enhance
the observation.
Key
1 high refractive index prism
2 block with plane surface cut from spectacle lens
3 contacting liquid
4 telescope
Figure 3 — Schematic diagram of the Abbe refractometer
Instruments are generally calibrated directly to give the refractive index.
NOTE Optically, an Abbe refractometer can only measure samples with refractive index lower than that of its
prism. This often gives an upper limit for measurement of the refractive index of 1,700. Similarly, the contacting liquid
has to have a refractive index at least that of the sample.
5.4 Practical results
Because of the difficulties in sample preparation, the results are not as precise as those summarised in
Table A.1. For the purposes of spectacle lenses, a minimum accuracy of 0,01 is required. The results from
experiments on spectacle lens samples are presented in Annex B.
1) If the instrument is not directly calibrated for refractive index, it can be calculated from the formula:
nnsin()sin () cos()s in() where n is the refractive index of the prism and α and δ are defined in Figure 3.
p p
6 “Classical” non-destructive methods
6.1 Sagittal depth gauge and radius of curvature methods
6.1.1 Accurate theory and considerations
The radii of curvature of the surfaces of a lens can be measured directly using reflection instruments or by
using a sagittal depth gauge to measure the depth (sag) across a known chord. The radii of curvature, in
metres, can then be calculated from the sag formula, Formula 1, where s and c are in millimetres:
sc
r or sr1000 ()1000 rc (1)
2000s
where
r radius of curvature of a surface of a lens, in metres;
s is the sagittal depth, in millimetres;
c is the semi-chord, i.e. half the distance between the two outer pins for a 3-pin instrument, or
the radius of the annulus for a ring-based instrument, in millimetres.
If the radii of curvature of the surfaces of a lens are known, application of the surface power equations
allows a calculation of the refractive index. The theory is as follows:
Formula 2 gives the back vertex power of a lens:
F
F' F (2)
v 2
t
1F
n
where
F’ is the back vertex power of a lens;
v
-1
F and F are the front and back surface powers, in D (m );
1 2
t is the centre thickness, in metres;
n is the refractive index of the material of the lens.
The surface powers can be expressed in terms of their radii of curvature in metres, r and r respectively,
1 2
using Formula 3:
n 1 1n
F and F (3)
1 2
r r
1 2
Formula 2 can then be rewritten as Formula 4:
n1
r 1n
F (4)
v
t n1
r
1
n r
Formula 4 can be simplified and solved as a quadratic equation for n in terms of r , r , t and the back vertex
1 2
power. In the usual quadratic equation, an + bn + c = 0, the coefficients and solution are given in Formulae 5
and 6 respectively:
11 tF '
v
a
rr r
12 1
tF '
11 2t
v
b F' (5)
v
rr rr r
12 12 1
t 1
c F'
v
rr
12
and
bb 4ac
n (6)
2a
where the positive root is taken for positive powered lenses, the negative for negative powered lenses.
The larger the chord, 2c, the larger the sag, s, (approximately proportional to c ). Hence, an error in the
measurement of the sag will cause a smaller error or uncertainty in the calculated radius for larger
chords than shorter ones (again, approximately proportional to c ). For example, for a surface of power
+6,00 D on a lens with a refractive index of 1,500, an error of 0,001 in the index is generated by an error or
uncertainty of 0,001 2 mm (1,2 μm) for a chord of 20 mm diameter as opposed to an error or uncertainty
of 0,005 mm (5,0 μm) for a chord of 40 mm diameter.
Conversely, if the surface is aspherical by design or inadvertently from the surfacing process, the larger the
chord, the greater the probable deviation from an assumed spherical surface. For the same surface as above,
it requires a p-value of 0,448 for the 20 mm chord as opposed to 0,869 for the 40 mm chord to give an error
of +0,001 in the index, a smaller amount of elliptical flattening from the assumed spherical shape, for which
p = 1,000. Negative errors of 0,001 in the index are produced by p-values of 1,560 and 1,137 respectively,
which correspond to steepening ellipses.
Instruments working by measuring the reflected beam provide the curve along the 2 principal meridians;
mapping devices often use an aperture in the region of 8 mm diameter at every point while single point
measurement devices often use an aperture of 4 mm diameter, similar to that used by focimeters
(lensmeters). Depth gauges can be supplied in various diameters. The British firm, OTI (Optical Tools for
Industry, https:// www .opticaltools .co .uk states that a digital clock gauge to measure the sag can be accurate
to 10 μm, while a Heidenhain linear gauge can be accurate to 0,1 μm.
Obviously, a ring-based depth gauge cannot be used on a toroidal surface, and only a measuring system that
uses a small area could be used on a power-variation lens since the surface power will be relatively uniform
in only the primary reference point’s measurement area.
6.1.2 Approximate or simplified theory and considerations
By expanding the fraction and ignoring terms higher than F , Formula 2 can be simplified to become
Formula 7:
t
FF FF (7)
v 11 2
n
If the term in F in Formula 7 is also ignored, i.e. the lens is regarded as a “thin lens”, and the powers
expressed in terms of the refractive index of the lens and the surface radii, Formula 7 can be simplified to
Formula 8:
Fn()1 (8)
v
rr
12
where
F the vertex power, as it now no longer matters which orientation the lens is in – but see below;
v
r and r are the radii of the two surfaces and are regarded as being positive if convex, negative if concave;
1 2
n is the refractive index of the material of the lens.
Rearranging Formula 8 to determine n gives Formula 9:
F
v
n1 (9)
rr
Some simple instruments, e.g. the “lens measure”, are frequently calibrated in surface power for a specific
index, often 1,530, rather than radius of curvature. In this case, the actual refractive index can be calculated
from Formula 10:
F
v
n11()n (10)
c
FF
12
where
F and F are the indicated front and back surface powers;
1 2
n is the refractive index used for the calibration of the instrument.
c
tF⋅
The omission of the term in Formula 8 onwards can lead to significant errors, particularly for positive
n
powered lenses where both the thickness and front (convex) surface power are greater than for negative
[7]
powered lenses. Burek recommended that for these positive-powered lenses, the calculation in Formulae 8
or 9 will be more accurate if based on the front vertex power, i.e. with the lens reversed from its usual
orientation in the focimeter(lensmeter). As an example, consider a lens of BVP +5,00 DS with a front surface
power of +8,00 D, back surface power of -3,21 D, centre thickness of 5 mm and index 1,600. Based on the
back vertex power, the calculated index according to Formula 9 is 1,626 whereas based on the calculated
front vertex power, the index is 1,604.
Annex D describes the effects of some errors in sag measurement.
6.2 Immersion methods
6.2.1 Theory
For a lens that is immersed in a medium of refractive index, n , Formula 8 needs rewriting as Formula 11:
M
Fn()n (11)
v M
rr
12
This shows that the power of a lens depends on both its refractive index and that of the surrounding medium.
By immersing the lens in a fluid of known refractive index, a new vertex power can be determined.
From Formulae 8 and 11, the values of the VP in air and in the medium can be shown to give the refractive
index of the lens as shown in Formula 12:
nF F
Mivvn airin medium
n (12)
FF
vvin air in medium
where
F is the vertex power measured in air
v in air
F is the vertex power measured in the medium with the lens in the same orientation as when
v in medium
measured in air
t
This method relies on approximating the real lens as a thin lens by omitting the term ⋅F in Formula 7. As
n
described in 6.1.2, the value of this is greater for a positive powered than a negative-powered lens, because
of both the greater centre thickness and the higher convex/front surface power. The effect of this can be
minimised to give better estimates for the refractive index if the lens is turned over, and the front vertex
2) Using the sign convention adopted for Formula 8.
powers in air and with the immersing device are used, i.e. always do these measurements with the more
steeply curved surface oriented towards the focimeter's or lensmeter’s lens support.
With astigmatic-power lenses, care is taken to use the power in the same meridian both in air and in
the medium. Using the principal meridian of larger absolute power will probably give better results.
Measurement of power-variation lenses could lead to uncertain results since the powers in the two situations
are measured in an area of stable power – perhaps well above the fitting cross for progressive-power lenses
or in the near portion for degressive-power lenses.
6.2.2 Measurement apparatus – Go-Meisan method
Provided the focimeter or lensmeter supports the lens in a horizontal plane, a potentially simple way to
immerse the lens is to put it with its convex surface downwards on a shallow container with flat bottom
(or just a glass disk) on the lens support. Just a drop of fluid can be sufficient to immerse the convex surface
around the central area used during the measurement. The measures described in 6.2.3 can be applied to
ensure a flat liquid surface for the concave side. A correction to the vertex power as measured ‘in air’ and ‘in
medium’ can be applied to compensate for the container (or glass disk) optical thickness.
A convenient method to immerse the lens is the Go-Meisan accessory. This consists of three pairs of gel-
filled shallow cylindrical containers with a plane afocal bottom and a flexible upper surface that moulds to
the curvature of the spectacle lens. Each set covers a range of powers with their expected range of surface
curvatures. The vertex power of the lens is measured in air, and then the appropriate pair of Go-Meisan
devices pressed onto the front and back surfaces of the lens, and the power remeasured. These values are
then substituted in Formula 12, with the index of the medium taken as 1,472 5.
The difference between the absolute value of the powers measured in air and when sandwiched between the
Go-Meisan devices decreases as the absolute value of the vertex power in air decreases. This results in less
accurate estimates of the refractive index for lens powers numerically less than 2 D, while it is impossible to
determine the index of an afocal (plano) lens since the vertex powers in air and in the device are both zero.
The results obtained by the working group suggest that this method is capable of evaluating the refractive
index of lenses to within 0,02, which is sufficient to differentiate many lens materials. Inspection of
Formula 12 suggests that reducing the vertex power of the lens when it is in the device is likely to improve
the accuracy of the method, especially for higher index lenses. Attempts, however, by the manufacturer to
make a device with a higher index gel were unsuccessful.
As with measurement of radii and power, using the focimeter (lensmeter) measurements with positive-
powered lenses reversed gives better results than using the conventionally measured BVP. Taking the
numerical example in 6.1.2, calculations show that the indicated refractive index measured using this device
with back vertex powers is 1,595 as opposed to 1,599 when using front vertex powers.
6.2.3 Another immersion method
6.2.3.1 Principle and theory
A collimated beam of light from a laser is shone down through the lens, and after refraction the beam will
appear to diverge from its virtual focus for a negative-powered lens or will converge to a real focus and then
diverge for a positive-powered lens. The diameters of the beam on a measuring screen without the lens, with
the lens and with the lens immersed in fluid are all measured, and knowing the distance from the lens to the
screen enables the focal length and hence power to be calculated.
The following formulae are written on the basis that lengths are measured in Cartesian form using the
shallow container and lens as origin, the pair being assumed to be thin in the optical sense. Distances are
positive if measured in the direction of travel of the light. The diameters of the beams are regarded as being
positive. d needs to be large enough to facilitate measurement, especially when using simple geometric
measurement methods. If more accurate methods are employed, such as capturing images of the beam and
determining the diameter through image recognition algorithms, then the size requirements can be relaxed.
3) Go-Meisan is the trade name of a product supplied by Tokai, and marketed by other instrument manufacturers, e.g.
Nidek.
Being collimated, the diameter d of the laser beam at the screen without the lens and when incident on the
lens are assumed to be the same. Since the incident beam is collimated, the image points, virtual in Figure 4,
are at the principal focus in image space for the two conditions – in air and in water or other medium.
a
In air.
b
In medium.
Figure 4 — Principle of the metho
...



